Fire Island Car Rental

Search and Compare from Car Companies in Fire Island

Photo by Carole Polney
I have a discount code

Featured car rental suppliers

Compare from agencies

car supplier logos

Compare car suppliers to unlock big savings, and package your flight, hotel, and car to save even more.

Members save 10% more on select hotels, cars, activities and vacation rentals. Sign up.Opens in a new window

Enjoy maximum flexibility with penalty-free cancellation on most car rentals.

Top Car Deals in Fire Island

* Price found within the past 6 days. Click for updated prices.

Mon., Jul. 21 to Tue., Jul. 22

Compact

Nissan Versa Note or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
Nissan Versa Note

CA $81

total
found 15 hours ago
Compact Nissan Versa Note
Mon., Jul. 21 to Tue., Jul. 22

Economy

Ford Fiesta or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
Ford Fiesta

CA $84

total
found 15 hours ago
Economy Ford Fiesta
Mon., Jul. 21 to Tue., Jul. 22

Special

Dealers Choice or similar
  • 4 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
Dealers Choice

CA $84

total
found 15 hours ago
Special Dealers Choice
Mon., Jul. 21 to Tue., Jul. 22

Standard

Volkswagen Jetta or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
Volkswagen Jetta

CA $91

total
found 15 hours ago
Standard Volkswagen Jetta
Mon., Jul. 21 to Tue., Jul. 22

Full Size

Nissan Altima or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
Nissan Altima

CA $94

total
found 15 hours ago
Full Size Nissan Altima
Mon., Jul. 21 to Tue., Jul. 22

Midsize

Toyota Corolla or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York City, New York, USA
Toyota Corolla

CA $82

total
found 15 hours ago
Midsize Toyota Corolla
Mon., Jul. 21 to Tue., Jul. 22

Midsize Elite

Tesla Short Range Model 3 or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Jamaica, New York, USA
Tesla Short Range Model 3

CA $119

total
found 15 hours ago
Midsize Elite Tesla Short Range Model 3
Mon., Jul. 21 to Tue., Jul. 22

Standard Elite Special

Ford Mustang Mach-E or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Jamaica, New York, USA
Ford Mustang Mach-E

CA $119

total
found 15 hours ago
Standard Elite Special Ford Mustang Mach-E
Wed., Jul. 23 to Thu., Jul. 24

Premium Pickup Regular Cab

Ford F150 or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York City, New York, USA
Ford F150

CA $153

total
found 5 days ago
Premium Pickup Regular Cab Ford F150
Thu., Jul. 24 to Fri., Jul. 25

Full Size Elite Pickup Regular Cab

RAM 2500 or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York, New York, USA
RAM 2500

CA $130

total
found 2 days ago
Full Size Elite Pickup Regular Cab RAM 2500
Wed., Jul. 23 to Thu., Jul. 24

Luxury

Genesis G70 or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York City, New York, USA
Genesis G70

CA $182

total
found 5 days ago
Luxury Genesis G70
Mon., Jul. 21 to Tue., Jul. 22

Luxury Elite

Genesis G80E or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York City, New York, USA
Genesis G80E

CA $226

total
found 15 hours ago
Luxury Elite Genesis G80E
Wed., Jul. 23 to Thu., Jul. 24

Premium Elite Crossover

Cadillac XT6 or similar
  • 5 people
  • Unlimited mileage
New York City, New York, USA
Cadillac XT6

CA $272

total
found 5 days ago
Premium Elite Crossover Cadillac XT6
Mon., Jul. 21 to Tue., Jul. 22

Mini Van

Chrysler Pacificia or similar
  • 7 people
  • Unlimited mileage
Jamaica, New York, USA
Chrysler Pacificia

CA $274

total
found 15 hours ago
Mini Van Chrysler Pacificia

Don't see what you're looking for?

See all car rentals in Fire Island
View all cars
Lowest prices found within the past 15 hours. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Frequently asked questions

What happens if I need to cancel my Fire Island car reservation?
When you cancel at least six hours prior to the pickup time, the majority of bookings offer a total refund. However, not all are eligible for this, so it's important to read your rental agreement. Look over your booking for the specifics or click through to our Customer Service Portal for more information.
How do I find the best car rental deals in Fire Island with Expedia?
Scoring an amazing deal on your Fire Island rental car is easy with Expedia. Choose your preferred car class, add in a few more details and compare prices across top brands. Why not add flights and hotels to your booking? You'll get access to even bigger savings when you combine your bookings into a package.
How old do you have to be to rent a car in Fire Island?
Anyone with a valid driver's license 21 and above can rent a vehicle in Fire Island. While some suppliers may be willing to accommodate drivers younger than 21, they will add on fees. Find out what ages the young driver surcharge applies to, and what it costs, before booking your wheels. Providers also restrict the categories of cars available to young drivers. Higher limits are in place for large vehicles like premium SUVs and luxury models.
What do you need to rent a car in Fire Island?
While terms and conditions can differ between rental car outlets, the basics are a current driver's license and a credit card. You don't need to take out the company's auto insurance. However, proof of your own coverage may be required.
Can I rent a car for a month or longer in Fire Island?
You can, and the awesome news is suppliers often offer lower rates the longer you rent. Scroll through our long-term car rental deals in Fire Island and drive away with an unbeatable bargain.
Where can I find a Fire Island car rental if I am younger than 25?
This will depend on the rental companies that are found in Fire Island. They often have different age policies. If you've found an outlet that does cater to drivers under 25, bear in mind that additional fees may apply. Do some research into what those charges could be before picking up your vehicle.

Car Rental Information

Popular car types:
SUV, Full Size, Economy
Car suppliers available:
Our best deal of the day:
CA $81
Our second best deal of the day:
CA $82
Our third best deal of the day:
CA $84
From the airport to your hotel:
Airport Transportation